Discover the FREE PLAYBOOK from World’s Best Marketers Claim Your Copy Now!

How to select the perfect digital marketing agency for your niche?

White label digital marketing services

By Christopher Benson on Mar 3, 2021

With everyone having access to the internet, the barriers to enter the digital world are slim to none. But the common dream of becoming an internet sensation turns to reality for a precious few. Most entrepreneurs spread themselves too thin, and navigating through multiple channels of digital media seems a daunting job to them. Hence, they need to discover the ideal digital partner to transfer their online marketing duties. 

As online businesses are rising in number, we see a mounting wave of prospective customers searching for services on the web. With 81% of Americans going online daily, it is needless to emphasize the power of a solid digital presence. Finding the right digital marketing agency that can cover all aspects of inbound and outbound marketing is crucial to your bottom line. 

While the market seems abundant with digital marketing agencies, it is not genuinely useful as most of the agencies are learning on the fly, and partnering with the wrong one can drain your brand image in no time. 


To assist you in putting your business in the big leagues, you must learn the key strategies to find the perfect marketing partner. 


Assess your business needs

Before you even start exploring the right marketing agency for your niche, dig deep into the territory of your company to evaluate your internal needs. The better you examine your business needs, your niche, and the business objectives that you aspire to attain through digital efforts, the better your marketing partner will decipher your goals.

Besides identifying critical areas that are not up to par, ask yourself the below questions to get a clear picture of the services, you require from the agency.

  • Do I need a niche agency that specializes in my domain of marketing?
  • Do I want this digital marketing as an extension of my in-house marketing team?
  • Do I want to target my core business functions and handoff marketing efforts to a third- party?
  • What is my expertise, and what areas will I outsource to a digital partner?
  • How much of my marketing budget is allocated for digital marketing campaigns?
  • How much time can I invest in this partnership?

Now when you have outlined your business-specific requirements, you can equate them with the intended services.

Seek total transparency

A study revealed by eMarketer states that 53% of business professionals are concerned about fraud. While there are several reliable digital marketing agencies in the market, the lucrative arena of digital advertising also lures a lot of swindlers. Such agencies promise the world and deliver an atlas. The best approach to avoid such partnerships is to study to distinguish between contenders and pretenders. 

  • Complete transparency should be the first criterion when partnering with any agency. 
  • Look into agencies’ records to determine their credibility and engagements. 
  • Refer to the testimonials and contact them to know beyond the details published on the website.
  • Check for the website’s Google ranking and social media content.
  • If the agency has engagements in your niche, enquire about the challenges and respective solutions.


With the ever-changing digital marketplace, it’s vital to find an agency that keeps pace with the latest trends and strategies. Make sure to assess their aptitude for the hot marketing tools and their employment to drive growth in your niche.


Uncover their KPIs

Most professionals monitor vanity metrics, such as the number of likes and comments on social media posts. But do they directly convert to sales? No, they are not really connected to revenue generation. Measure the success of your prospective partner by tracking the following essential digital marketing metrics.

  • Number of unique visitors:
    Agencies with a solid marketing funnel can conveniently convert traffic to conversions. Generation of traffic and their interaction with the website is a quick way to determine their marketing competency.
  • Click through rate:
    The analysis of the count of their ads that have been clicked versus the number of impressions they received can help you understand how targeted their marketing approach is.
  • Cost per click:
    Do they utilize this purchasing model for paid ads?
  • Bounce Rates:
    If the website has high bounce rates, it points to irrelevant and invaluable content that drives visitors away after landing on the website.


Plan for a long-term relationship

Digital marketing isn’t as naïve as throwing a dice and watching the number rolling in. It is a continuous and complex process that takes time to deliver results. As developing a result-oriented marketing approach demands long hours, businesses should be mindful of the fact that they need to establish strategic and long-term relationships with digital partners. When working with an agency on the same page, it is crucial to hand off your brand image to a trusted partner. Long-term relationships can benefit both clients and marketers immensely as both can rely on each other for valuable feedback.

Ask for Pricing

When touching the final ground, pricing will certainly be a determining factor. But it’s unwise to hunt for the cheapest options or discounts because they bear a high probability of causing you damage in the long run. This is also not an indication to invest millions of dollars in your digital marketing strategies. The U.S. Small Business Administration advises investing 7%-8% on marketing.

If you want the best value for your money, find a perfect balance between pricing and quality. Discuss with the marketing agency to get comprehensive details of the services they offer and their requirements. 




The role of digital marketing agencies has been instrumental in the successful journey of businesses, and the process of finding the right one that drives business growth doesn’t have to be stressful. However, an array of a few elements demands your attention before you commence hiring a digital marketing agency. Make sure to have a deep understanding of your target market and stay persistent with your marketing efforts.

If you believe you are inexpert in running inbound campaigns that yield ROI, then you should hire a digital marketing agency to outsource your marketing needs. The right digital partner can not only generate high revenue for your business but also imparts peace of mind by handling everything that pops up without throwing up hands in the air.


Learn how to pick the right digital marketing agency for your niche by identifying business internal pain points and outlining clear expectations from a digital partner.

Share This Article

Subscribe to our newsletter

Join 150,000 marketing managers who get our best digital marketing insights, strategies and tips delivered straight to their inbox.


    Subscribe to The Marketing Umbrella Podcast

    Where we interview leading experts on ways to build and grow your business

    Get a FREE copy of this top seller book – BUILDING THE ULTIMATE MARKETING AGENCY

    Get the strategies and practical tactics from the world’s leading marketers, to grow your agency without breaking the bank!

    Building The Ultimate Marketing Agency - Book by Itamar Shafir

    >> Get Your Free Copy Here

    Building the Biggest Local Marketing Agency in The World - Together!


    Talk to us today and start growing your business

    (866) 760-2638

    img img

    Download Umbrella’s secret prospecting tactic we use in our call center to generate 1000’s of appointments every month!

    The PR Revenue Tactic guide

    To pack your pipeline with high paying prospects


      *The guide will be emailed to you

      We will never share your data with anyone